Principles of the Referee Process

Principles of the Referee Process

Preliminary Review and Plagiarism Check
Manuscripts submitted to the journal must be unpublished, not currently under review by another journal, and approved by all authors.
Submissions are first reviewed by the editor in terms of the journal’s purpose and scope, publication policies, academic writing guidelines, and the APA 7 citation system. Manuscripts deemed suitable during the preliminary review are subjected to a similarity check using Turnitin software. The acceptable similarity rate must be below 20%. However, regardless of the similarity rate, quotations that are not properly cited are considered an ethical violation.

Subject Editor Review
Manuscripts that pass the preliminary review stage are evaluated by the relevant subject editor for scientific merit, originality, methodology, academic language, and alignment with the journal’s scope. Manuscripts deemed suitable are sent for peer review.

Peer Review
The Journal of Balkan Studies employs a double-blind peer review system. Manuscripts are sent to at least two independent external reviewers who are experts in the relevant field and have a track record of academic publications.
Reviewers are expected to evaluate the manuscripts according to the following criteria:
•    The originality and scientific contribution of the study,
•    The clarity and significance of the research question,
•    The appropriateness of the methodology and research design,
•    The scientific consistency of the findings and conclusions,
•    The adequacy of the literature review and the accuracy of source citation,
•    The quality of language, presentation, and academic writing,
•    Compliance with ethical principles and publication guidelines.
The review period for referees is 20 days. If necessary, this period may be extended by 10 days.
If one reviewer provides a negative opinion while the other provides a positive opinion, the manuscript is sent to a third reviewer. At least two positive reviewer opinions are required for the manuscript to be published.

Revision and Review Process
If the reviewers request revisions, the review reports are forwarded to the author. The author is expected to resubmit the manuscript after making the necessary revisions in accordance with the reviewers’ recommendations.
Revisions must be made using the “Track Changes” feature in Word or by clearly marking the text.
The revised manuscript is first reviewed by the subject editor. If deemed necessary, it is sent for re-review by the referees. The referees evaluate whether the requested revisions have been implemented.

Language Review and Preparation for Publication
Manuscripts that successfully complete the peer review process are reviewed by language editors if deemed necessary.
Following language review, the manuscripts undergo typesetting and page layout. The final text prepared for publication is sent to the author for review.

Editorial Board Decision
Once peer reviews, subject editor comments, and required revisions are complete, the manuscripts are submitted to the Editorial Board for evaluation.
The final decision regarding whether a manuscript will be published, revised, or rejected rests with the Editorial Board.
When making its decision, the Editorial Board takes into account the peer review reports, the manuscript’s originality, scientific merit, methodological adequacy, compliance with ethical principles, and the journal’s scope and objectives.
The Editorial Board may request additional peer reviews or academic evaluations when deemed necessary. Positive peer review reports do not, by themselves, guarantee that a manuscript will be published.

Ethical Principles and Confidentiality
Authors, editors, and reviewers are required to disclose any potential conflicts of interest. Individuals with conflicts of interest may not participate in the evaluation or decision-making processes for the relevant manuscript.
Reviewers are obligated to keep the content of the works they evaluate confidential. The identities of authors and reviewers are kept confidential during the review process. Reviewers must conduct their scientific evaluations in an impartial, constructive manner and in accordance with academic ethical standards.

Publication and Open Access
Manuscripts approved for publication by the Editorial Board are published following the completion of final reviews.
The Journal of Balkan Studies adheres to an open-access publication policy. All published articles are accessible online and free of charge to readers.
Bibliographic data for published issues are submitted to relevant national and international indexes.